Advertisement
Get your first 12 issues for just £12
SUBSCRIBE
Money

Student loans: This generation is getting a raw deal

The cards are increasingly stacked against young people going into higher education in England and Wales. What can be done?

Illustration of a student struggling while carrying a heavy coin

Illustration: Sam Peet

A level results are here. Half a million young people are thinking about whether to take up an offer of a place, take out a student loan and move away from home. No one wants to put a young person off going into higher education, but thanks to changes in government policy the cards are increasingly stacked against young people going into higher education in England and Wales. 

Times have changed

Huge financial decisions have to be made swiftly, something anyone over the age of 55 just didn’t have to do. Back then, there were no university fees. In fact, free money called “grants” was given to students to cover their rent and living costs. How times have changed.

Charging our young people sky-high fees is a political choice. If Austria, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Poland, Slovenia, Scotland, to name a few countries, all manage to provide higher education for free, why can’t we? 

Today’s young people in England and Wales face a very different student experience. Those from the poorest backgrounds will take on the most debt and pay back their loans for longer. Meanwhile, the richest 10% of students avoid 40 years of repayment by paying their fees upfront and escaping the student loan system completely.

Furthermore, few parents realise that since 2012 they are expected to cover the gap between student maintenance loans and actual living costs. For many families facing stratospheric mortgage interest rates and inflation, it is simply not an option.

The loan term

First-time students and post-graduate students starting this September face an extra 10 years of repayment compared to previous students. That means that many young people will still be paying back their student loans when in their 60s. Another intergenerational unfairness foisted on the young.

Advertisement
Advertisement

The interest rate

Previously, students were charged the rate of inflation plus another 3% interest on top while at university. However, post-pandemic inflation saw student loan interest rates rise to around 13%. While the government has capped those rates, from September 2023 new students will still be charged 7.1%, which is well above the rate at which the government can borrow.

Some experts argue that the amount of interest charged does not matter as it is the repayment rate that counts the most. Intergenerational Foundation (IF) calls this just another form of intergenerational unfairness, placing too much of the burden of wanting a higher education on the shoulders of individual students rather than seeing higher education as a form of public investment in the doctors, policemen, nurses and other professions on which our GDP depends. 

The repayment threshold

The student loan system is income contingent, meaning graduates do not have to start paying back their loans until they earn over a set threshold. Theresa May acknowledged that students had been hard hit and raised the repayment threshold in line with inflation. The current government appears to be less sympathetic and has instead lowered that threshold to £25,000 using a tax trick called fiscal drag – which literally pulls lower earners into the repayment system sooner. 

The repayment rate

Again, the current government could have reduced the repayment rate in order to help young people cope with the crippling cost of living crisis driven largely by inflation and high housing costs – since food and energy prices affect their generation as much as any other. Instead, the government has kept the repayment rate at 9%. If reform is ever on the agenda then reducing the repayment rate would be the most helpful to the young.

What is the government trying to achieve by pursuing this strategy?

The current government seems to be wedded to the idea of the marketisation of higher education, and refuses to accept that former university minister David Willetts’s grand experiment of turning higher education into a market, upon which he defended the tripling of tuition fees, has failed. There is no market. Most institutions rushed straight to full £9,000 fees when they were tripled in 2012.

Since then, higher education institutions have gorged on student debt, grand expansion projects and pay and pension perks. Let us not forget the £700,000 pay and pensions package rewarded to one vice chancellor, or Louise Richardson, former VC of Oxford University, commenting that vice chancellor pay should be likened to the international football market. Those with skin in the game forget that football markets are commercial, while higher education institutions should be run for the public good.

The Blair dream of sending 50% of young people on to higher education, may not be in the best interests of young people today. When close to 50% of recent graduates are working in non-grad jobs (over 30% for non-recent graduates) do we need to have a national conversation about whether 40 years of student debt, with no graduate pay premium, is worth it? Are there better routes into the workplace via degree apprenticeships, or apprenticeships? Until these different markets mature, what teacher or parent wants to discourage their child from getting a higher qualification?

Who benefits from student debt?

Now that student debt has to be accounted for on the government balance sheet and cannot be sold off to the private sector, there seems little point in front-loading debt, charging high rates of interest or demanding high repayments, all of which was used to create a new asset class. We already have a progressive tax system, one in which the more a person earns, the more tax they pay. Students are definitely not the winners if they are left with 40 years of repayment without any increase in pay to show for it. 

Student maintenance loans

While other generations have seen their benefits rise by inflation year-on-year during the cost of living crisis, students have been pretty much ghosted by policymakers. Student maintenance loans will increase by just 2.8% from September, resulting in many more students having to live at home – if they have a home to live in. No wonder the number of students with part-time jobs has risen by 25% in the last year. Hidden homelessness is also on the rise. A 2022 survey by the National Union of Students in Scotland found that 12% of students had experienced homelessness since starting their studies, rising to one in three among estranged and care-experienced students.

Get the latest news and insight into how the Big Issue magazine is made by signing up for the Inside Big Issue newsletter

What can be done?

Intergenerational Foundation believes that higher education should be a public good that enriches society and provides the highly educated workers on which our economy depends. International comparisons demonstrate that a free higher education system is achievable, especially when we already have a progressive tax system, one that charges more tax the more people earn. After everything the young gave up to shield older generations during the Covid-19 pandemic, the least we could do for them is to invest in their futures more fairly.

Liz Emerson is the co-founder of Intergenerational Foundation

Do you have a story to tell or opinions to share about this? We want to hear from you. Get in touch and tell us more.

This article is taken from The Big Issue magazine, which exists to give homeless, long-term unemployed and marginalised people the opportunity to earn an income.

To support our work buy a copy! If you cannot reach your local vendor, you can still click HERE to subscribe to The Big Issue today or give a gift subscription to a friend or family member.

Advertisement

Become a Big Issue member

3.8 million people in the UK live in extreme poverty. Turn your anger into action - become a Big Issue member and give us the power to take poverty to zero.

Recommended for you

View all
Easy hacks for books and apps that every student should know
Student Life 2024

Easy hacks for books and apps that every student should know

How to live your best student life without breaking the bank. No, seriously
Student Life 2024

How to live your best student life without breaking the bank. No, seriously

How to navigate the new social world of university life – no matter your background
Student Life 2024

How to navigate the new social world of university life – no matter your background

Dear students: Here's how to get smart about money and save yourself stress later on
Student Life 2024

Dear students: Here's how to get smart about money and save yourself stress later on

Most Popular

Read All
Renters pay their landlords' buy-to-let mortgages, so they should get a share of the profits
Renters: A mortgage lender's window advertising buy-to-let products
1.

Renters pay their landlords' buy-to-let mortgages, so they should get a share of the profits

Exclusive: Disabled people are 'set up to fail' by the DWP in target-driven disability benefits system, whistleblowers reveal
Pound coins on a piece of paper with disability living allowancve
2.

Exclusive: Disabled people are 'set up to fail' by the DWP in target-driven disability benefits system, whistleblowers reveal

Cost of living payment 2024: Where to get help now the scheme is over
next dwp cost of living payment 2023
3.

Cost of living payment 2024: Where to get help now the scheme is over

Strike dates 2023: From train drivers to NHS doctors, here are the dates to know
4.

Strike dates 2023: From train drivers to NHS doctors, here are the dates to know